|
So you need a cavity filled? The assistant
called it a "restoration". Uh, oh!! Sounds like you
might need a building permit! And it raises a lot of questions.
How could this happen? Weren't those old fillings supposed to
last for ever? How come you need to replace them anyway? Did
the last dentist do a bad job? How can you be certain that the
next one will last? How long should a filling last anyway? It'll
probably hurt and cost a fortune! Should you just put in the
cheapest filling or just what the insurance pays for? The insurance
company will only pay for a silver filling, but the dentist wants
to do a gold one. Why should you do that? Why should you have
to pay so much for the work anyway? If the insurance doesn't
cover it, is it necessary? Certainly the insurance company knows
best....don't they? After all, they pay for a lot of fillings.
Maybe you should get a second opinion? Can you really trust the
second opinion? Yikes!! What's a patient to do these days? The
following will give you more insight into this myriad of choices.
Shotless, painless, noiseless cavity
preparation is now a possibility.
To learn more, click here.
Dental Filling
Materials: Pro's and Con's
Composite
Resin Fillings
Glass crystal epoxy resin fillings also known as direct composite
resin fillings have revolutionized dentistry for more than 20
years now. These tooth colored fillings are fairly strong, very
esthetic and almost invisible when placed in a tooth. Statistics
show that composites are increasing in popularity and are replacing
amalgams in many offices nationwide. Are they all they seem to
be? Is there a downside you should know about? Even though patients
are asking for them in increasing numbers, there are significant
advantages and disadvantages that you should be aware of.
Advantages:
1. Composites look like real teeth.
2. Composites are chemically bonded directly to the tooth &
create a better seal.
3. Composites are light cured which makes them hard instantly.
4. Composites have excellent strength for small to medium size
fillings.
5. Composites are poor conductors of temperature..
Disadvantages:
1. Composites get weaker when the cavity is too large.
2. Composites are brittle and don't have good edge strength.
3. Composites cannot be placed in a wet area (under the gumline).
4. Manufacturers give them a relatively short lifespan. (5-7
yrs.)
5. Some composites are sensitive afterwards and don't get better.
It is not clearly understood why this happens, but it does. Sometimes,
you take your chances having a composite done.
Silver
Fillings:
Over the past 100 years, silver fillings have proven to be very
reliable and still the most widely used restorative material
in the United States. Perhaps you have one of these metallic
fillings yourself. Are they safe? What is all the hoopla about
their toxicity?
Silver fillings have become controversial
in recent years because they are mixed with mercury at their
placement. Critics in recent years have stated that this mercury
is toxic to human beings and have begun an extensive movement
to educate the public against their use. In many cases, this
educational program has caused panic, misinformation and inappropriate
use of composite throughout the mouth, weakening the teeth.
Regardless of the bad press, extensive
studies have been done by the Centers for Disease Control,
the National Institute of Health and the American Dental
Association and as of this posting, silver is still recommended
for restoration of small to medium large cavities. For more on
this important topic, see our article on mercury toxicity
Advantages:
1. Fairly strong from small to large fillings.
2. Fairly good edge strength, so it doesn't tend to chip until
late in it's life.
3. Relatively cheap.
4. Placed in one appointment.
5. Can be used in a wet field.
6. Can last 5-20 years or longer in some cases.
Disadvantages:
1. It flows under pressure and may cause teeth to crack.
2. It is not bonded to tooth structure and tends to leak
3. Used inappropriately as silver crowns when gold or porcelain
should be used.
4. Needs to set after placement and is weak for first 10 hours
or so.
5. Conducts temperature very well and may contribute to cold
sensitivity.
6. Unproven claims of metal upsetting the electrical meridians
of the body have been made.
7. Mercury toxicity has been suggested but not proven.
Regardless of the controversy, we still
see silver fillings that have been in place for decades. The
durability of this material must be weighed alongside it's accused
drawbacks.
Porcelain
Porcelain remains the most beautiful restoration we place in
dentistry. Unlike silver or composite which is placed in one
appointment, porcelain must be fabricated by a laboratory technician
and is baked in an oven at almost 2000 degrees Fahrenheit, requiring
a minimum of two appointments to complete treatment.. Porcelain
is one of the most durable cosmetic materials in dentistry and
has launched a complete revolution in cosmetic possibilities
this past decade. It has definite pluses and minuses as well.
Advantages:
1. Porcelain is extremely esthetic and lifelike.
2. Porcelain is extremely strong and has lifetime characteristics.
3. New "Empress" (type) Porcelain is
the most lifelike porcelain available today and can create outrageously
beautiful cosmetic results.
4. Porcelain can be bonded directly to tooth structure.
5. Porcelain is not a good conductor of temperatures.
Disadvantages:
1. Porcelain is harder than enamel or gold & can cause excessive
wear.
2. Very expensive
3. Requires a minimum of two appointments to fabricate and place.
4. Porcelain is brittle and can fracture.
5. Technique sensitive. Requires artistry to maximize the esthetic
possibilities.
Gold
Gold has been the benchmark of the highest quality permanent
dentistry possible for almost a hundred years. It continues to
be used today in many areas of dentistry and is still considered
one of the standards of the profession. Why would you want gold
fillings anyway? Is it really worth the price and rigmarole to
place in your teeth? As all things, there are advantages and
disadvantages, even with the best materials.
Advantages:
1. Extremely accurate and durable material.
2. May be cast to extremely fine marginal detail.
3. Gold is about the hardness of enamel and wears at the rate
of the teeth.
4. Gold is not brittle and cannot fracture.
5. Gold can have porcelain bonded to it for fabrication of cosmetic
crowns.
6. Gold is bio-compatible and non-toxic.
Disadvantages:
1. Gold is very expensive.
2. Gold requires two appointments to fabricate and place.
3. Gold is a great conductor of temperature.
4. Yellow gold may not look esthetic when used in cosmetic zones.
5. Gold is not bonded to tooth structure and may leak over time.
6. Gold may interfere with the electrical meridians of the body.
|